From Gas Station to Local Legend: The 50-Year Evolution of Kill Devil Hills’ Jolly Roger Restaurant

When you drive down Beach Road in Kill Devil Hills today, the eclectic exterior of Jolly Roger Restaurant stands as a testament to five decades of Outer Banks culinary history. What began as a humble gas station and grocery store in the early 1970s has evolved into one of the most beloved dining establishments on the Outer Banks, serving up an unforgettable blend of Italian cuisine, fresh seafood, and local charm.

Humble Beginnings: The 1972 Transformation

The year was 1972 when the former gas station first transformed into what would become an OBX dining institution. While other restaurants might have stripped away the building’s past, Jolly Roger embraced its unique history, incorporating elements of its service station days into the eclectic décor that now defines the space.

“We’re eclectic, it’s crazy. You’ll not find another Jolly Roger; there’s no rhyme or reason to this place and that’s what people love about it,” says owner Carol Ann Angelos, whose vision has shaped the restaurant for four decades.

The Angelos Legacy: 40 Years of Service

In December 2022, Carol Ann Angelos was honored with a Certificate of Appreciation from the Dare County Board of Commissioners, recognizing her 40 years of dedication to the Outer Banks community. Under her leadership, Jolly Roger has become more than just a restaurant – it’s a gathering place where locals and visitors alike create lasting memories.

Building a Culinary Tradition

What sets Jolly Roger apart isn’t just its unusual origins or distinctive atmosphere. The restaurant has established itself as the Outer Banks’ original Italian restaurant while simultaneously mastering the art of coastal cuisine. Every sauce is house-made from scratch, with each recipe carefully taste-tested to ensure excellence.

From Simple Station to Culinary Destination

Today’s Jolly Roger offers:

• Award-winning breakfast (recognized as Best Breakfast 2016 by Best of the Beach)
• Fresh-caught local seafood
• Prime rib and steaks
• Traditional Italian dishes
• House-made sauces and specialties
• Live entertainment and community events

Community Hub and Entertainment Venue

The evolution of Jolly Roger continues as it serves as a hub for local entertainment, featuring:

• Live music performances
• Karaoke six nights a week
• NTN Trivia contests
• Poker tournaments
• Holiday celebrations
• Special community events

A Legacy of Innovation

While maintaining its historical charm, Jolly Roger has adapted to modern times, now offering:

• Online ordering through DoorDash and Uber Eats
• Family package take-out specials
• Late-night dining options
• Regular entertainment schedule
• Daily specials and happy hour deals

Looking to the Future

As Jolly Roger celebrates over 50 years of service to the Outer Banks community, it stands as a reminder that sometimes the most unexpected transformations yield the most remarkable results. From filling gas tanks to filling plates, this Kill Devil Hills landmark continues to evolve while staying true to its unique character.

Plan Your Visit

Experience this piece of Outer Banks history yourself at 1836 N. Virginia Dare Trail, Kill Devil Hills. Open daily for breakfast, lunch, and dinner from 7:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m., with late-night food available until midnight in the bar on Fridays and Saturdays.

Looking for more information about Jolly Roger Restaurant or planning to visit? Call us at (252) 441-6530 or check our daily specials and entertainment schedule on our website.